Ground Level

Crema Is a Freshness Gauge, Not a Quality Score

Crema is gas, oil and fine coffee whipped together under pressure. It tells you the beans are fresh and the machine has pressure. It does not tell you the shot is any good.

Someone in a hoodie leaning on a kitchen bench looking at a fresh espresso with thick crema

Thick crema does not mean good espresso. It means fresh beans and enough pressure. Those are two different things, and the coffee world has spent nearly 80 years letting you mix them up.

Here's what crema actually is. Roasting fills coffee beans with carbon dioxide. Force hot water through fresh grounds at around 9 bar and that gas comes out as thousands of tiny bubbles, whipped together with coffee oils and the very finest grains of coffee. That foam is crema. Gas, oil and dust, held together by pressure.

Every one of those ingredients is about freshness and pressure. Not one of them is about whether the beans were any good to begin with.

We know this because of where we judge our coffee. Every batch that comes off the roaster is cooled, left in drums overnight to de-gas, then cupped before it's cleared to go anywhere. Cupping is ground coffee steeped in a bowl with hot water and no pressure at all. There is no crema on a cupping table. It's the one place in the roastery where we decide whether a coffee is right, and crema isn't in the room.

A barista in a 1940s Italian bar pulling the lever on a chrome lever espresso machine

Crema Was Marketing From Day One

Until the late 1940s, espresso machines ran on steam. The coffee came out dark, flat and a bit burnt. Then Achille Gaggia built a machine with a spring lever. Pull the lever down and a piston pushed water through the coffee at far more pressure than steam could manage, and for the first time a shot came out with a layer of foam on top.

Customers hadn't seen it before and some of them thought something had gone wrong. So the Milan bars with the new machines put up signs calling it crema caffè, a natural cream from the coffee itself. Nobody had asked for crema. It was a side effect of pressure that got given a name so it would sell.

That's the whole origin story. A lever, a sign, and 80 years of people reading quality into a layer of foam.

What Crema Tells You (and What It Doesn't)

Crema is a gauge. It reads three things, and quality isn't one of them.

Freshness. Beans give off CO2 from the day they're roasted, and crema runs on CO2. That's why there's a one-way valve on the bag. Most coffee is at its best for espresso somewhere between 1 and 3 weeks off the roast. By 4 weeks the gas is mostly gone and so is the crema, however good the beans were. The crema goes well before the coffee stops being worth drinking.

Pressure. No pressure, no crema. A plunger, a V60 and a cupping bowl make none and nobody minds. A machine with a tired pump, or a shot that races through because the grind is too coarse, makes a thin pale layer that's gone before you've reached for the milk.

The basket. This is the one that catches people out. Most home machines, Breville included, ship with two sets of baskets. One set has a single wall with hundreds of tiny holes. The other, the pressurised or dual-wall set, has a second outer wall with one small hole in it. That one hole creates the pressure the coffee itself can't, and the foam forms after the hole as the shot sprays into the cup. You get a big airy head of bubbles from pre-ground supermarket coffee that's months old. It looks like crema. It isn't telling you anything.

Roast and bean type move the needle too. Very light roasts make little crema no matter how fresh they are. Robusta makes more of it, thick and long-lasting, which is one reason the old Italian blends carried some. Neither of those is a quality signal either. When a bag shouts rich crema on the front, that's what it's promising. Gas.

What you see What it's telling you
Thick, smooth, golden brown, holds for a couple of minutes Fresh beans, real pressure, grind in the right zone. Now taste it.
Thin, pale, gone in 30 seconds Old beans, or the grind is too coarse and the shot ran too fast
Big loose bubbles that collapse as you watch A pressurised basket doing the work, not the coffee
Hardly any, but the shot tastes clean A very light roast, or beans past 3 weeks. Taste wins.
None at all You made filter coffee. That's allowed.
Two espresso cups side by side, one with thick golden crema and one with a thin pale layer

Try the Skim Test

James Hoffmann won the World Barista Championship in 2007. A couple of years later he wrote that crema was rubbish, and his test is one you can run tomorrow morning.

Pull two shots of the same coffee. Leave one alone. Take a teaspoon and skim the crema off the other, the way you'd skim fat off a stock. Taste them side by side.

Most people find the skimmed one smoother and less bitter. Crema on its own is harsh. Those fine grains and bubbles carry a lot of the sharp, drying side of the coffee, so the pretty layer on top is the roughest-tasting part of the shot.

You don't have to skim your espresso forever. Plenty of us like the look, and stirring the crema through changes the taste again. The point is smaller than that. If the best-looking part of the shot is the worst-tasting part, looks were never the measure.

No Crema? Check These Before You Blame the Beans

When a shot comes out flat, go down this list in order. It's the order we'd check at the roastery.

Check What to look for
Roast date Over 4 weeks old? That's your answer. Under 5 days? Still de-gassing, give it a couple more days.
Grind Shot done in under 20 seconds, thin and watery? Go finer. A proper burr grinder is the fix if yours can't get there.
Dose Weigh it. Guessing by eye swings a gram or two, and that's enough to flatten a shot.
Basket Dual-wall? Swap to the single-wall set in the box. Crema will drop at first while you dial in. That's real feedback arriving.
Machine Pump near 9 bar, group head and shower screen clean. Old coffee oils in the group taste like old coffee oils.

Where we start on People Everyday, straight from the brew guide:

Dose Yield Ratio Water Time
20 g 40 g 1:2 93°C 27 to 30 seconds

Hit those numbers on beans inside 3 weeks of the roast date and the crema takes care of itself. Then stop looking at it and taste.

A roaster leaning over a row of cupping bowls with a cupping spoon, flat black coffee and no crema

The BOM Take

Crema tells you the beans are fresh and the machine has pressure. Taste tells you whether the coffee is any good. We decide every batch at a table where there's no crema at all, and we'd rather you judged your shots the same way. Fresh beans, a real grinder, a single-wall basket, and your mouth, not your eyes.

Keep reading: How to Dial In Espresso at Home · How to Store Coffee So It Actually Stays Fresh · Same Beans, Different Drink: Espresso vs Filter · The Brew Guide

Want to see what fresh crema looks like in your own cup? Start with People Everyday, a medium roast that's great with milk, or pick a blend.

Next Monday, 7am: why cafe coffee tastes thicker than yours at home.

Written by Jos at Brother of Mine, specialty coffee roasters in Perth.

Scene sound off