Your Regulars Are Too Polite to Tell You the Truth
Your regulars say yes to every new idea because they like you. The Mom Test gives you three rules for questions that get the truth instead, and one test for whether a yes is real.

You asked 11 regulars if they'd come to a Friday night thing. Wine, a cheese board, lights down, a bit of music. All 11 said yes. 4 came. 2 of them were staff.
Nobody lied to you. They like you. And when someone who likes you asks whether their idea is any good, the honest answer and the kind answer are rarely the same answer.
Rob Fitzpatrick spent years asking customers about his first company and hearing yes. The company failed anyway. The book he wrote afterwards is called The Mom Test, and the title is the whole idea. Ask questions so specific that even your mum couldn't lie to you about them.
Cafe owners ask the polite version all day. Do you like the new banana bread? Would you come in if we opened evenings? Would you still come if the flat white went up 50 cents? Every answer comes back warm. Every one of them is close to useless.

Three kinds of answers that feel like data and aren't
Fitzpatrick sorts the useless answers into three piles. Once you can see them, you'll hear them at the counter every day.
Compliments. "Love it." "Great idea." "You should definitely do that." A compliment is the sound of someone being nice to you. It tells you nothing about where their money goes next Friday.
Fluff. Generic claims about the future. "I'd totally come to that." "I always try new things." "I'd probably grab beans from you." Anything with would, probably, usually or always in it is fluff. People are describing the person they'd like to be, not the one who walks past your door at 7:10 with a train to catch.
Ideas. "You know what you should do? Breakfast burritos." Ideas feel like gold because someone cared enough to have one. They're not a request. They're a passing thought that cost the customer nothing and will cost you 3 weeks and a new supplier if you act on it.
All three are about the future, or about opinions. Nobody can lie to you about last Tuesday. Counting the yeses and calling it research is the same trap as judging a decision by one good week. It feels like evidence. It isn't.

The three rules
The book comes down to three rules. They fit on a napkin.
Talk about their life, not your idea. The moment you describe the Friday night thing, every answer is about you. Ask what they did last Friday instead. Where they went, what it cost, who they were with, whether they'd go back. If Friday night in their life is the couch and a takeaway, no amount of enthusiasm at your counter is going to change that.
Ask about specifics in the past, not opinions about the future. "Would you buy our beans for home?" gets a yes. "What did you brew this morning, where did you buy it and when did it run out?" gets the truth. One of those conversations tells you there's a bag of supermarket coffee in their pantry that they grabbed in a hurry with the groceries. That's a customer you can win. Yes told you nothing.
Talk less. Listen more. Owners are good talkers. It's part of how you got the cafe. But every minute you spend pitching is a minute they spend working out how to be nice about it. We've covered the listening half of this before and the rule is the same here. Ask the question. Then stop talking and let them fill the gap.
Here's what that looks like on the questions a cafe actually asks.
| The polite question | The Mom Test question |
|---|---|
| Would you come in if we opened Friday nights? | What did you do last Friday night? What did it cost you? |
| Do you like the new banana bread? | What did you order here last week? What did you nearly order and skip? |
| Would you still come in if the flat white went up 50 cents? | Where else did you buy coffee this week? What did you pay? |
| Would you use a loyalty app? | Which loyalty things are on your phone right now? Which did you sign up for and never open again? |
| Would you buy our beans to take home? | What did you brew at home this morning? Where did it come from? |
Notice the right-hand column never mentions your idea. That's not an accident. The idea is the thing they'd be polite about. Their last Friday night is just a fact.

A yes that costs nothing is worth nothing
Here's the part of the book most people skip, and it's the part that saves you money.
Even a good conversation ends with a feeling, and feelings aren't orders. Fitzpatrick's test for whether a yes is real is whether it costs the person something. Time, reputation or cash. A regular who says "sounds great" has spent nothing. A regular who puts their name and a $20 deposit down for Friday night has told you the truth with their wallet.
So every one of these conversations should end with a small, real ask. Pre-order the new thing. Put your name on the list. Bring one mate next Friday. Take a bag home today at the normal price and tell me next week what you reckon. If they do it, you've learned something. If they don't, you've also learned something, and it cost you nothing to find out.
What you don't do is run a survey. A survey is the polite question with a clipboard. Every "would you" and "how likely are you" on it is fluff with a number attached, and the number makes it look like evidence.
And if the decision you're sitting on is a price rise, this is the step before putting the price up. Not whether they'd mind. What they're actually paying elsewhere, this week, for what.

Do this before the next decision
Pick one decision you're sitting on. The evenings, the price, the new line, the retail shelf. Write 3 questions about it that are only about the past and don't mention your idea at all.
Ask them at the counter while the coffee's being made. 5 regulars in a day. Don't pitch. Don't explain why you're asking. Write down what they said, word for word, not what you hoped they meant.
Then count commitments, not compliments. Who did something? Who paid, pre-ordered, put a name down, took a bag? That number is your research. The warm feeling you got from everyone else is proof you run a cafe people like. Which is nice. It's just not the question you asked.
We've been on the wrong end of this too. Put a new blend in front of an owner and ask if they like it, and they do. Every time. The conversation that actually tells us something is the one about what's on the bar right now and how it got there. Nobody says that to be nice.
Further reading: The Mom Test by Rob Fitzpatrick
Inspired by The Mom Test by Rob Fitzpatrick. If this hit home, the book goes deeper.
Keep reading: The Good Week That Is Hiding a Bad Call · How to Win Every Difficult Conversation
Want a Perth coffee roaster who asks what's on your bar right now, not whether you like our new blend? Let's talk wholesale.
Next Sunday, 5am: the pay rise didn't fix it. Here's what would.
Keep reading
More from First Light.



